Welcome to SmallPie

A Café & Gift Shop in Bay View, Milwaukee

We are a counter-service café specializing in:

  • Handmade savory & sweet pies

  • Fresh sandwiches & biscuits

  • Homemade cookies & treats

Made from scratch by our team of chefs and bakers, just like grandma used to make.

Enjoy Our Full Drink Menu

  • Craft coffee drinks

  • Refreshing non-alcoholic beverages

  • Select beer, wine & cocktails

Visit Our Gift Shop

Featuring fresh flowers, plants, and curated gifts from Buttercup Urban Gardens.

Relax on our spacious, dog-friendly patio!

BIG HEARTS Our pies may be s m a l l (sometimes) But our hearts are BIG! (always) Sending you love through all the goodies (edible and floral) that we sell today, and EVERYDAY. Be kind, spread love. Stay sweet, Bay View 💝
BIG HEARTS Our pies may be s m a l l (sometimes) But our hearts are BIG! (always) Sending you love through all the goodies (edible and floral) that we sell today, and EVERYDAY. Be kind, spread love. Stay sweet, Bay View 💝
BUTTERCUP IS BACK We are beyond excited to announce that we will be working more intimately with @buttercupmilwaukee YEAR ROUND! This means... 💐 weekly flower deliveries from @karthauser1 (tulips for now, look forward to other varieties in the fut
BUTTERCUP IS BACK We are beyond excited to announce that we will be working more intimately with @buttercupmilwaukee YEAR ROUND! This means... 💐 weekly flower deliveries from @karthauser1 (tulips for now, look forward to other varieties in the future) 🫛 seeds from @driftlessseeds 🌱 seed starters from @hsugrowingsupply 🪴 a limited selection of local houseplants 🧑‍🌾 other garden essentials like @woolletsllc and @deerdefeat ♻️ look forward to [hsu] soil and compost as the weather warms this is, of course, in addition to our favorite local vendors @fern_and_nettle @wilsoncreekpottery @camino.woodshop @milwaukeemicrogreens and many more!! interested in becoming a vendor? send us a DM to ROOT the conversation! we can’t wait to GROW with you in the future!
WELCOME BACK In celebrating the return of our FAVORITE General Manager, we’ve decided to make Mo’s BFF, LINK our January DOG of the MONTH! This last month, Mo was out of commission recovering from ACL surgery, but being tough as crust,
WELCOME BACK In celebrating the return of our FAVORITE General Manager, we’ve decided to make Mo’s BFF, LINK our January DOG of the MONTH! This last month, Mo was out of commission recovering from ACL surgery, but being tough as crust, she’s already back and ready for action 👊💢 Thank you, Link, for keeping Mo company while she was away! You may miss having her home all the time, but we’re sure glad she’s back spreading joy within our community. Think your mutt, cat, ginuea pig, etc has what it takes to be Pet of the Month? Bring ‘em over and strike a pose! Tag us in the best shot for a chance to win!
LAST CHANCE! If you, like us, forgot to get some goodies for a few people on your list - you’re in luck! We have a mix of… 🌱 URBAN GARDEN MERCH Inspired by @buttercupmilwaukee, we’ve stocked up on our favorite tools and supplies
LAST CHANCE! If you, like us, forgot to get some goodies for a few people on your list - you’re in luck! We have a mix of… 🌱 URBAN GARDEN MERCH Inspired by @buttercupmilwaukee, we’ve stocked up on our favorite tools and supplies from vendors like @milwaukeemicrogreens @pottingshedcreations @thelushstudio_plantcare @flawnseedkits and MORE 🏠 HOUSEHOLD GIFTS Including @fern_and_nettle @bestpysanky @abbottgiftware and @marissakayapothecary 🥧 BAKED GOODS All your favorites from @honeypie_bakeshop! WHOLE PIE orders still available for walkup TODAY or order for 12/24 by calling 414.242.6389 We will be closed Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. HAPPY HOLIDAYS!
THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME… …for DOG OF THE MONTH! She’s got beauty, she’s got grace, She’s got “I’ve been a good girl this year” written all over her face… IT’S MIA! Congrats to Mia and
THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME… …for DOG OF THE MONTH! She’s got beauty, she’s got grace, She’s got “I’ve been a good girl this year” written all over her face… IT’S MIA! Congrats to Mia and her family for winning this month’s DOG OF THE MONTH! In collaboration with @bentleyspetstuffbayview, as Dog of the Month, Mia will be receiving 🐾 an adorable gift set from our favorite pet shop 🐾 a $15 gift card to SmallPie to share with the family CONGRATS AGAIN! Think your mutt, cat, ginuea pig, etc has what it takes to be Pet of the Month? Bring ‘em over and strike a pose! Tag us in the best shot for a chance to win!
BIG HEARTS Our pies may be s m a l l (sometimes) But our hearts are BIG! (always) Sending you love through all the goodies (edible and floral) that we sell today, and EVERYDAY. Be kind, spread love. Stay sweet, Bay View 💝 BUTTERCUP IS BACK We are beyond excited to announce that we will be working more intimately with @buttercupmilwaukee YEAR ROUND! This means... 💐 weekly flower deliveries from @karthauser1 (tulips for now, look forward to other varieties in the fut WELCOME BACK In celebrating the return of our FAVORITE General Manager, we’ve decided to make Mo’s BFF, LINK our January DOG of the MONTH! This last month, Mo was out of commission recovering from ACL surgery, but being tough as crust, LAST CHANCE! If you, like us, forgot to get some goodies for a few people on your list - you’re in luck! We have a mix of… 🌱 URBAN GARDEN MERCH Inspired by @buttercupmilwaukee, we’ve stocked up on our favorite tools and supplies THE MOST WONDERFUL TIME… …for DOG OF THE MONTH! She’s got beauty, she’s got grace, She’s got “I’ve been a good girl this year” written all over her face… IT’S MIA! Congrats to Mia and