Fill your bellies with sweet and savory pies, hot sandwiches and other yummy treats from the baking and culinary team of Honeypie.

A FACELIFT! With the state of the world this last week, we needed something to turn the corners of our mouth up 😊 Some new additions to our pretty new menu include: 🍅 Tony’s Tomato Pesto Sammie 🐔 Wendy’s Chicken Bacon Ranch Sammie Not to mention all the yummy treats which rotate regularly to fill any voids that may have been created. As always, thanks for the love and support Bay View. We make one heck of a community when we come together 🫶 See you soon!

CONGRATS LILY! While Lily’s parents make sure she is always traveling in comfort and style, this girl has learned where to find the best PIE in town!! That’s why this month, Lily has taken the crown as our NOVEMBER DOG OF THE MONTH!! In collaboration with @bentleyspetstuffbayview, as Dog of the Month, Lily will be receiving 🐾 an adorable gift set from our favorite pet shop 🐾 a $15 gift card to SmallPie to share with the family CONGRATS AGAIN! Think your mutt, cat, ginuea pig, etc has what it takes to be Pet of the Month? Bring ‘em over and strike a pose! Tag us in the best shot for a chance to win!

HAPPY HALLOWEEN From Pumpkin Amy Winehouse, Erin, & Mo, we wish you the spookiest of seasons! Open today til 5pm, so get your TREAT on before the sun goes down 🍬🍫🍭 Spook you soon! 👻

🍂🍁🍃 We are LOVING this fall weather!! Our heated patio helps keep you cozy while watching all the leaves change color. What’s YOUR favorite part of Autumn in Bay View?!

WELCOME FALL! New season means new stuff here at SmallPie!! You can look forward to… 🍁 NEW cookie flavors! Like Lemon Poppyseed and Toffee 🍃 NEW wallpaper! We told you we were getting a facelift 🍂 NEW sandwiches! Coming next week 👀 What’s YOUR favorite NEW thing in Bay View? Tell us in the comments below so we can explore with you!!

ABOUT US

We are a small, neighborhood, counter-service cafe specializing in handmade savory and sweet pies and treats. We opened in August 2018. We bake and make all of our treats in small batches with a lot of great Wisconsin ingredients. Our team of chefs and bakers roll each buttery pie dough by hand for each pie just like our grandmas did, so each pie is flaky and delicious. We have a wonderful patio for watching the neighborhood pass by. We hope you enjoy every bite!

SmallPie is part of the PIE Inc team which includes our sister cafes Honeypie, Comet and Palomino as well as our baking kitchen, the Honeypie Bakeshop here in Milwaukee and in Chicago. We believe great food, and especially great pie, is one of the best ways to make our neighborhood and city a more wonderful place. Since 2005 we have worked hard everyday to make delicious, belly-warming food, to be a fun and healthy place to work and to bring value to our community. Thank you for visiting!